Steel vs. Plastic Compost Bins: Which One Should You Choose?

When you want to choose a compost bin for your yard or garden, you have two common options: steel and plastic. Each style has its own pros and cons, so make sure to consider them before you make your selection. Here’s a look at the pluses and minuses of steel and plastic compost bins, and how to decide between the two.

Steel Compost Bins: The Good and Bad

These compost bins are sturdy and long lasting. They withstand bad weather and are less prone to cracking or breaking like plastic bins. Steel bins wear better; ideal for the future. They’re also effective at keeping rodents out, meaning that animals won’t be able to access your compost.

But steel bins are weightier and less portable. They also cost more upfront than plastic bins do. Steel bins can also rust over time if it's not maintained properly. Rust also weakens the bin, and could affect its longevity.

What’s Good About Plastic Compost Bins

Plastic compost bins are lightweight and easy to move, which is nice if you want to switch up the location of your compost pile. They are more affordable than steel bins, which is nice for those on a budget. And plastic bins don’t rust, which trickles down the list of ways they can help you if you live in a wet region.

The main disadvantage is that plastic bins are not as durable as steel bins. In really bad weather, they can crack and break easily. Plus, they don’t typically last as long as steel bins, so you might need to buy new ones on a more frequent basis.

Steel Compost Bins vs Plastic Compost Bins

When you choose between plastic vs steel compost bins, consider what your most pressing needs are. If you want something substantial and durable, you may also prefer a steel compost bin. But for those who place a premium on price and ease in moving it around, plastic compost bin may be a better option.

A Few Considerations in the Steel or Plastic Compost Bin Decision

Budget: Consider how much you can spend on a compost bin. Steel bins typically have a higher up-front cost but may save you money in the long term due to their increased durability.

Durability: Factor the weather into account where you live. If it’s really awful outside, chicken coop with run a steel bin may prove to be more appropriate. But if you are looking for something light and easy to move around, a plastic bin may be a better choice.

Maintenance: Consider how much time you want to spend caring for your compost bin. Steel bins must be cared for to prevent rust, and plastic bins are more low-maintenance.

Both compost bins made out of steel and plastic have pros and cons. Before making your decision, consider what you need. Whatever compost bin you choose — steel or plastic — be sure to follow good composting practices so your organic waste decomposes properly.